| | |
|
| |
| | |
|
|
| | |
|
Netgear ReadyNAS NV+ wins Editors Choice Award
- PC Magazine
This product has several outstanding points. Hefty storage
capacity that's easily expandable is one—you're not locked in to the drives that
came with the device. Speed is another - the
NV+ is fast. Real fast. It can actually
make all this newfangled media-serving stuff work, and that's truly impressive.
The
easy storage expansion comes courtesy of the patented X-RAID
technology. Unlike normal RAID technology, X-RAID doesn't
require new drives to have exactly the same capacity as the
units they replace. That lets you scale the NAS upward
incrementally. Most buyers will probably start with the
basic version of the NV, which is built around four 250GB
disks. But the machine can support today's 750GB drives and
will be able to handle higher-capacity storage devices as
they become available. This means that you can insert a
single larger drive without having to rebuild the NAS,
something you can't do with a standard RAID device.
The fast transfer rates of the
Netgear ReadyNAS NV+ will,
generally, count for more in the home than the office, since
home users are more likely to want media-streaming
capabilities. Typical NAS boxes run under 10 MBps for most
data transfers—fast enough for data work, but too slow to
prevent artifacts in movies. With my typical small network
setup, which consist of a DSL modem, a gigabit switch, and a
variety of PCs running Windows XP and Vista, Linux, and Mac
OS X, I clocked the NV at up to 30 MBps for both general
data transfers and media streaming. That's plenty fast
enough for smooth streaming video.
For disk writes, transfers
slowed to just under 20 MBps and can slow further if you're
using small frame sizes or features like full journaling
(which few home users would run). In any case, home users
should have no performance worries with the
ReadyNAS. The unit can
stream multimedia for the SlimBox media server series or act
as an iTunes server, sending music to connected iPods—you
can enable either capability by checking the appropriate box
for it during setup. The OS supports other media adapters
via UPnP.
Netgear
also did a lot of homework to make the NV a good fit for
SMBs. Setup, for example, can integrate the device into an
environment with just one PC, a small workgroup, or a home
setup where the PCs see each other but there's no central
server. The NAS can also integrate directly under an
Active Directory (AD)
domain, which is how most small business networks run. The
Iomega StorCenter 200d, for example, works this way with
Windows networks, since it's running Windows Storage Server
as its OS.
The NV is slightly harder
to install, though not much, and has the advantage that its
features work with more than Windows clients. You'll
probably have a few more hiccups importing large lists of
users and groups from AD with the
ReadyNAS, but if you've
even got one client machine that's not Windows, it's well
worth the effort.
Additionally, the NV takes
good care of IT administrators. Setting up user accounts is
easy, and once you've installed the RAIDiator software on
the client, you can map the NAS as a single share or to
whatever shares that user has access. If there's a problem
with a drive, or someone changes a NAS configuration
setting, the NV will e-mail alerts to IT personnel.
Storage-savvy IT administrators will also like getting much
greater flexibility in performance tuning than with most
competing boxes. Admins can play with cache sizes, frame
sizes, data journaling, and more until the way the NV runs
perfectly suits the needs of the business.
Overall, I thought this
product was elegant and well thought out - not, for the most
part, because of the admittedly impressive transfer speeds
or huge storage capacity, but for little things: RAIDiator's
support for five languages, for example. Or, when you first
plug the NV in, the feature that checks to see if your
network has a DHCP controller and adjusts the configuration
accordingly to avoid conflicts.
For tasks like image
backups, the
ReadyNAS NV requires you to
install a third-party product, such as Symantec's Ghost
(which worked just fine in the labs). Window Home Server
takes care of that for you. But, in general, the NV can do
everything WHS can and more. In addition, the NV supports
clients running an OS other than Windows. Initially, a WHS
appliance will likely be cheaper than a 1TB NV, but that's
probably for a 500GB machine. For home users the NV is an
attractive purchase. For small-business use, I've yet to see
a better all-around NAS box—period. Unless you're absolutely
a Windows-only house, the
ReadyNAS NV is byte for
byte a better value, and wins our Editors' Choice.
| |
| | |
|
|
|